Paris's Other Mirror

Paris - Another Mirror

"Mirror, mirror, who is the fairest of all?" Indeed, Paris is beautiful, romantic, gentle, and noble. People know this without needing a mirror to tell them: "Paris is beautiful," "Paris is the best," "Paris is paradise on earth," "Paris is the homeland of bohemians." This illusion has long haunted the world, attracting thousands of people. Many are illegal or economic migrants; some flee oppressive regimes, risking their lives to cross behind the Iron Curtain. Others seek better living conditions, freedom, or a future for their children, sacrificing themselves in this metropolis. Life away from home is rarely satisfactory; everything seems harder than climbing to heaven. Without legal residency, one has no identity and cannot exist formally, forced into an underground life unseen by the sun. Earning a living, supporting a family, or finding work brings further hardship. It requires not just diverse skills but extraordinary courage. How to overcome all this? From another perspective of existence, their will and courage are truly admirable.

In the post-deconstruction era of the 1990s, over these short ten-plus years, people witnessed wave after wave of illegal immigrants sneaking into European Union countries, risking their lives. This tide was felt in major European cities. Shocking tragedies and moving stories of illegal immigration did not arouse much public concern. On this contradictory and confusing issue, Europe failed to propose effective policies. Politicians turned a blind eye, acting as if nothing were wrong. A far-right undercurrent lies latent in society, ready to erupt at any time, as seen in incidents like the street killing of foreigners (not necessarily non-white) in Belgium. In Paris, people clearly see these crowds. More contradictorily, among many immigrant families, although most children can attend primary school, every winter and summer vacation marks the time for deportation. Thus, it is also when illegal immigrants go into hiding. One wonders what problem this solves. Such hot potato immigration policies only make society more contradictory and conflict-ridden. Predictions for the 2007 French presidential election suggest the far-right will emerge again.

The other side of France's mirror: Under the bravery and combat prowess of the French Blue Team, they defeated Portugal last night (July 5) with great joy, entering the World Cup final. Outside the window, the Triumphal March continued to play, and the Champs-Élysées was filled with celebrating crowds. Football drives people mad; victory is within sight. Looking at the members of the French national football team, one can see some signs. (Have you noticed?) Ninety percent of the team members are Black (people of color from French overseas territories). From a foreign perspective, someone joked that France is a Black country. Yet on the political stage, people do not see people of color. What is going on? This is worth serious thought.

遣送家庭及就學兒童的集會與示威遊行海報。
遣送家庭及就學兒童的集會與示威遊行海報。
集會拯救「Oscar」及其家庭海報。
集會拯救「Oscar」及其家庭海報。
巴黎街頭經常會看到游民流浪街頭的情景。
巴黎街頭經常會看到游民流浪街頭的情景。
巴黎街景:這是巴黎紅十字會分發給浪民的帳棚。
巴黎街景:這是巴黎紅十字會分發給浪民的帳棚。
當人們散步優美塞納河畔橋下卻住滿無家可歸的浪民。
當人們散步優美塞納河畔橋下卻住滿無家可歸的浪民。
在藝術散步橋下以彩繪塑膠布遮掩的浪民居所。
在藝術散步橋下以彩繪塑膠布遮掩的浪民居所。
在瑪琍橋下令人驚訝的浪民露營棚,這也是巴黎。
在瑪琍橋下令人驚訝的浪民露營棚,這也是巴黎。
在浮日廣場廊街上的一景,又是巴黎的另一面的鏡子。
在浮日廣場廊街上的一景,又是巴黎的另一面的鏡子。